We all have those things in our past that embarrass us or come back to haunt us. If we’re lucky, its not caught on tape or doesn’t leave a paper trail. Unfortunately for politicians, everything they say and do are recorded and their votes come back to beat them over the head if the legislation they vote for has unintended consequences or later becomes unpopular. One of the most haunting choices made by Democrats was the support of the 1994 crime bill. This is especially troubling for Joe Biden since he was a major force in writing the bill.
The 1994 crime bill was written during a time when tough on crime rhetoric was extremely popular, even among Democrats. Legislation cracking down was a slam dunk and enjoyed bipartisan support. I will not defend Democrats on this, they should have known better. The war on drugs was always racist, Nixon made that clear, and being tough on crime meant targeting poor and urban areas which dis-proportionally effects minorities. I understand that and I was 5 when the bill passed.
The crime bill expanded on laws that are widely believed to have exploded the prison population and led to an era of mass incarceration where America leads the world in prisoners in raw numbers by hundreds of thousands. Two percent of Americans can expect to be incarcerated with 2.2 million being in prisons at any given time. 65% of that population are minorities. The minority population in American prisons alone almost matches China’s entire prison population. That is, well, there are no words for how truly atrocious of a failing that is.
So when Trump/Pence criticize Biden for the crime bill, it’s justified. But media, reporters, interviewers, whoever is talking to them need to press the Trump administration what they would do to rectify the mistakes of the crime bill. Odds are, they wouldn’t have anything to say. That’s because they’ve already taken the law and order stance. They’ve taken the side of cops in racially charged shootings, criticized Black Lives Matter, and denied systemic racism is the justice system. They barely want to acknowledge racism exists at all and racial disparities in society. It’s easy to criticize the crime bill, but Trump and many Republicans are happy to continue the tough on crime policy that throw so many people into prisons. Right wing pundits are shouting in their echo chambers that Democrats are going to release prisoners and criminals because trying to help them is considered soft on crime. Trump even pardoned Joe Arpaio, who was found to be racially profiling for years arrested when he refused to stop racially profiling.
Democrats, to be fair, aren’t much better. After all its difficult to make the pitch to help criminals because we still have this idea that criminals are inherently bad people. Only the most progressive of elected officials and advocates are vocal about prison and drug reform. Here’s the thing though, they’re trying. Joe Biden plans to reduce mandatory minimum sentences. Some people are serving 55 years for a drug that’s now legal in several states. Some are serving life for ounces of a drug. Additionally Biden supports decriminalizing marijuana. It’s not legalization, but its a step because drug crimes affect minorities at a dramatic rate. Democrats in Florida recently allowed ex-felons to vote again, giving a voice back to those, again dis-proportionally affecting minorities, who have paid their debt.
So, one side, you have Trump who refuses systemic racism exists in the justice system, is reluctant and slow to disavow support from racists and white supremacists, and fights for monuments to literal traitors who fought America for the sake of slavery.
Then on the other side you have Biden who acknowledges the need to make a change. They’re slow, incremental changes, but its a start.
So, remember when Trump and pundits bring up the 1994 crime bill to claim Biden can’t fight for minorities, it’s just a distraction from Trump’s own problem with race and that he has no plan to address it.